Denny’s All American Sauce Recipe: 5 Easy Steps!

Are you tired of having to go all the way to Denny’s to get a taste of Denny’s All American Sauce? Do you want to enjoy your fries with something more than ketchup when you’re at home? 

Though the exact recipe of the sauce is secret, you can make it at home because you only need a few ingredients to make it. So, don’t worry; this article will help you make the delicious Denny’s All American Sauce recipe in your kitchen.

All About Denny’s All-American Sauce

Prepare to unlock the tantalizing mystery behind Denny’s Diner’s best-kept secret: the coveted All-American Sauce. This divine creation, reserved for selected dishes like the Double American Burger, Beyond Burger, and All American Burger, has won hearts as the culinary jewel of this 24/7 restaurant chain.

Crafted from the perfect union of mayonnaise and ketchup, this sauce is a true culinary chameleon, pairing flawlessly with rice, nuggets, or pasta. Its creamy texture, courtesy of the luscious mayonnaise, envelopes your taste buds in a sweet and tangy embrace, leaving a symphony of flavors dancing on your palate.

All About Denny’s All American Sauce

The beauty of this sauce lies not only in its extraordinary taste but also in its remarkable versatility. Easy to whip up in your own kitchen, it becomes a culinary companion for various dishes, adding a touch of magic to each bite. Plus, with the added benefit of a long shelf life, you can relish the joy of your homemade All American Sauce time and time again.

So, embrace the happiness of crafting this sensational sauce in the comfort of your home, and elevate your dining experience to new heights of satisfaction. Savor the enchanting allure of Denny’s All American Sauce as it takes you on a journey of culinary bliss, making every meal a delightful celebration of taste and togetherness.

Ingredients for Making Denny’s All American Sauce

Here are the ingredients needed for making Denny’s All American Sauce. You can always add or remove any component while making this sauce. However, add more ingredients to have a larger quantity of sauce.

  • Half a teaspoon of cayenne pepper 
  • 4 teaspoons of olive oil 
  • 4 Cloves of garlic
  • 2 cups of water
  • 2 teaspoons dried oregano
  • 2 tablespoons diced onion
  • 2 tablespoons dried basil
  • 2 cans of tomato paste
  • 2 cans of crushed tomato
  • 2 tablespoons diced celery
  • 2 tablespoons diced bell pepper
  • 3 tablespoons of brown sugar
  • 3 tablespoons of white sugar

Step-by-Step Process to Prepare the Denny’s All American Sauce

Once you have rounded up all your ingredients, follow the 5 easy steps below to make the creamy Denny’s All American Sauce at home. This recipe can serve nearly six burgers or two to three plates of fries.

#Step 1: Warm Up the Oil

Take a big saucepan, according to the quantity of sauce you are making, and add olive oil. Heat the oil on medium heat so the ingredients don’t get burned. Add cayenne pepper, diced onion, celery, crushed tomato, green bell pepper, and garlic.

#Step 2: Continue to Stir

Once you add the ingredients, keep stirring for about 8–10 minutes to cook them evenly. After 10 minutes, pour water and add white sugar, brown sugar, basil, oregano, and tomato paste. Don’t forget to mix them well.

#Step 3: Let it Boil

After a few minutes, the contents of the pan will start boiling. Stir them once or twice to ensure they don’t get burned at the bottom of the pan.

#Step 4: Let it Simmer 

Once they boil for 1-2 minutes, turn the heat down and let the sauce simmer on low heat for half an hour. It will increase the flavor of the sauce. By now, the unmistakable tangy aroma of the sauce will be too hard to miss.

#Step 5: Serve and Enjoy!

Take the sauce from the pan and transfer it to a clean bowl. To enhance the flavor more, keep it in the fridge for two days and then use it. Dip nuggets and fries in the homemade sauce and enjoy.

Denny’s All American Sauce Recipe: The Easy Version

If you don’t want to wait for nearly forty minutes to make the sauce through the steps mentioned above, then here’s an easy recipe to follow that you can make in five minutes with just five ingredients.


  • Ketchup
  • Mustard
  • Sugar
  • Onion powder
  • Mayonnaise

To make Denny’s All American Sauce with these five ingredients, mix them in a bowl, and Tada! Your sauce is ready to be enjoyed with a good juicy burger. You can add more mustard for extra spice or honey for a sweet flavor.

Denny’s All American Sauce
Denny’s All American Sauce

One ounce of Denny’s All American Sauce has nearly 180–200 calories and 25 grams of fat. The sweetness and sourness are from the ketchup, and the creamy texture is from the mayo. But both are high in calories, sugar content, and fat. If you are on a diet, use ketchup with zero calories and mayonnaise with low fat.

A Few Tweaks to Make the Sauce More Flavorful

Since you’re making this sauce at home, there are always options to customize the sauce in ways you prefer. So, here are some tips on how to enhance certain flavors.

  • The ingredients are always customizable when you are making this sauce. So, add sugar, spice, and salt according to your preference. 
  • If you want the sauce to be creamier in texture, then add yogurt or sour cream. 
  • When reheating the sauce, ensure you heat it on a low flame. The sauce will change its flavor with a high flame and be burnt.
  • Add extra tomato paste if you prefer the sauce to be thicker.
  • Honey or sugar can be included while cooking to get a sweeter taste. 
  • For enhanced flavor, use fresh-picked herbs instead of dried herbs. 
  • Adding smoked paprika to the sauce will give you a smoky taste. 
  • Add vegetable or chicken broth for a deep and rich flavor instead of water. 
  • For the long run, put them in separate reheatable containers and freeze them. 
  • Add some chopped chilies or mustard if you like a little spicy sauce. 
  • Add vinegar, soy sauce, lemon juice, or Worcestershire sauce to increase the tangy sour flavor.

What Dishes Can be Served with Denny’s All American Sauce?

It is one of the most popular sides of many dishes. With a burst of sweetness and spice, it’ll undoubtedly make your dish taste like heaven, be it chicken salad, chicken wings, fries, potato salad, burgers, vegetables, pasta, or rice. This recipe, with all its various ingredients, makes it suitable for pairing the sauce with multiple dishes.

Not only chicken salad or chicken wings, but Denny’s All American Sauce can also be enjoyed with seafood, roasted ducks, and roasted pork. Apart from being used as a dip, if you’re cooking at home, you can use this sauce for marinating the meat to add unique flavors. 

Are you making a sandwich? Add this sauce for a spicy, tangy twist to the taste. Always experiment; you’ll be surprised at how well this sauce will go with various dishes.

The Other Sauces You Can Enjoy from Denny’s

Apart from All American Sauce, there are more varieties of sauce offered by Denny’s as sides to their dishes. For example, they offer Buffalo sauce, Nashville Hot sauce, Tomato sauce, Sweet and Tangy BBQ sauce, and Bourbon sauce. 

Be it their famous Sirloin Steak or Nashville Hot Chicken Melt; these sauces will make them taste twice as savory. The best of these sauces are the garlic-flavored ranch sauce and the bourbon sauce, with their smokey and burnt caramel taste.

Final Words

The Denny’s All American Sauce recipe will make your evenings with family or game night with friends more flavorful. People with dietary restrictions can also make this sauce by adding low-calorie ketchup and low-fat mayonnaise.

So, with just a few ingredients, you’ll have a bowl of sour and sweet All American Sauce to make the burgers and salad even more delicious.

Above are the delicious and best recipes to make Denny’s All American Sauce from Hope you cook it well after reading our sharing

About The Author

Scroll to Top